Lesson: Rework, Reuse, Remix (6-8)

Warm-up (10 minutes)

REVIEW the Key Vocabulary terms as a class.

EXPLAIN to students that there are only two ways they can use copyrighted work without permission: (1) public domain, and (2) fair use.

SHOW students examples of public domain works:

• Project Gutenberg is a collection of free e-books (electronic books) that are in the public domain.
• “The Commons” on Flickr is an archive of photos in the public domain.

ASK: If you wanted to use any of these works in the public domain, what could you do with them?
Guide students to come up with specific answers. They can copy, share, distribute, perform, change, remix, and alter the work however they wish. However, they cannot claim copyright to public domain work and say they created it.

Learn About Public Domain and Fair Use (15 minutes)

DIVIDE students into discussion groups of four to six.

DISTRIBUTE the Four Points of Fair Use Student Handout. Students can refer to this handout throughout the lesson.

DISCUSS the definition of fair use in the Four Points of Fair Use Student Handout. Have students take turns reading aloud the directions and the definition of “fair use.” Explain to students that the four points help them judge whether something can qualify as fair use, as long as it falls into one of the situations listed inside the diamond.

Note: The term “fair use” means exactly what it says. It is a “fair use” of a copyrighted work without getting permission from the creator. It allows you to use copyrighted work without permission or paying a license fee in certain situations.

HAVE students look at the center of the diamond on the Four Points of Fair Use Student Handout.

EXPLAIN that fair use can be applied in only these four specific situations.

ASK: What are some examples of “schoolwork and education”?
Guide students to understand that in this fair use situation, students and teachers can use copyrighted material for school. For example:

• Teachers use copyrighted websites, video, music, photos, books, etc. in their classes for educational purposes
• Students use copyrighted photos for PowerPoint slides

ASK: What are some examples of “news reporting”?
Guide students to understand that in this fair use situation, reporters can use content such as copyrighted images and video clips to help tell their news stories. For example:

• A news journalist uses copyrighted photos and video clips in her articles to help illustrate or support an  article

ASK: What are some examples of “criticizing or commenting on something”?
Guide students to understand that this fair use situation describes when someone makes a creative work that adds his opinion, or makes people see something in a new way. For example:

• Making a video that’s a political statement about global warming that uses copyrighted images and video clips
• Making a video from movie and TV clips to pay tribute to your favorite actor

ASK: What are some examples of “comedy and parody”?
Review the Key Vocabulary term parody, if needed. For example:

• Making a video remix on YouTube that makes fun of a movie or TV show
• When a comedian takes a song and puts his or her own funny lyrics to it

HAVE students examine at the four points of the diamond. Explain that fair use can be used in these certain ways. Ask students to add their own examples.

• Use a small amount (not the whole thing)
  For example: Using a little bit of a song in a mash-up, not the whole song
• Add new meaning and make it original
  For example: Remixing clips from different movies to tell a whole new story
• Rework and use in a different way 
  For example: Using a copyrighted photo image as the basis for a painting
• Use for a nonprofit purpose 
  (It’s harder to claim fair use if you are making money off someone else’s work, or if you harm the creator’s ability to make money on the work you used) For example: Using a clip from a song in a student public service announcement about recycling (nonprofit use); Creating a remix video DVD and selling it on the Internet (for-profit use)

EXPLAIN to students that if they use a copyrighted image, video, piece of writing, etc. without reworking it enough to have new meaning and make it original, they could be breaking copyright law.

POINT OUT that the four points of fair use are just guidelines and not “rules.” People need to think critically, and proceed on a case-by-case basis, to decide whether or not something is fair use. Also point out that even if something is fair use, it is always a good idea to give credit to the creator of the work you used.

Judge the Fair Use of Case Studies (20 minutes)

KEEP students in their groups.

TELL students they will view examples of a video and a song in which the creator has reworked copyrighted material. They will then have to judge whether or not the new work is fair use.

SHOW students one or both of the case studies below.

HAVE student groups discuss whether or not they believe the case study is fair use, referring to their Four Points of Fair Use Student Handout. Have a representative from each group share their group’s final answers with the class.

Note: There are no right or wrong answers to each case study. These examples are meant to spark discussion. Students should support their decisions with sound reasons, drawing from the four points of fair use.)

Case Study 1: Scary Mary (10 minutes)

SHOW students the video “Scary Mary."

“Scary Mary” is a video remix of a fake film trailer. The creator, Chris Rule, reworked footage of the Disney film Mary Poppins and combined it with scary music, sound effects, and words on the screen that make it look like a horror film trailer. Note that Chris Rule acknowledged the copyrighted creative work he used at the end of the video.

ASK: Do you think this video falls under fair use? If so, why? If not, why not?
Sample responses:

Fair use:

• Only a small amount of the film was use
• It’s a parody making fun of Mary Poppins, like she’s scary
• It takes original movie clips but reworks them into something new
• The creator gave credit to material he used by listing it at the end of the video

Not fair use:

• All the clips were from the movie Mary Poppins, so it wasn’t original enough
• We don’t know if Chris Rule made money from his video, but if he did, it’s less likely to be fair use

Case Study 2: DJ Earworm’s “United State of Pop 2009” (10 minutes)

SHOW students the video “United State of Pop 2009."

DJ Earworm is a mash-up artist. He is known for his “United State of Pop” mash-ups in which he gives tribute to the top songs of the year. He creates both audio and video mash-ups. In his “United State of Pop (Blame It on the Pop)” mash-up from 2009, he used clips from 25 different songs, including Miley Cyrus “The Climb,” Alicia Keys’ “No One,” and the Black Eyed Peas’ “Boom Boom Pow.” On his website DJ Earworm says, “Basically, what I do is take a bunch of songs apart and put them back together again in a different way. I end up with tracks called mash-ups, which I post to this website.” He also says that he doesn’t make money from his mash-ups because he doesn’t sell them, and they’re free to download from his website. But he does get credit, and sometimes earn payment, for his songs through top ratings on YouTube, airplay on the radio, and when he’s featured on the Billboard music charts (which lists the top songs in the country).

ASK: Do you think this video falls under fair use? If so, why? If not, why not?
Sample responses:

Fair use:

• He makes a new, different song than the original songs he used
• He uses just a small amount from each song
• He gives credit for the songs he uses by listing them on his webpage
• He doesn’t make money from his remixed songs

Not fair use:

• None of this is orignal work – it’s all taken from other musicians
• He’s just ripping off the riffs from others’ songs
• His video isn’t original because it’s just clips from the original videos. He could have made a whole new video.

Make It Fair Use! (10 minutes)

TELL students to apply what they’ve learned by making a creative work using copyrighted materials that can be called fair use. Have students refer to their Four Points of Fair Use Student Handout for guidance. Follow the instructions for either the low-tech or high-tech option. Note that both options could extend the amount of time needed for the lesson. This step can be made into a homework assignment.

Option 1: Low Tech – Fair Use Collage
Have students cut out (copyrighted) images from magazines. Using glue and construction paper, have students mix images together into a collage. They should rework and change the images to create a new, original work that can be called fair use. Have students tape their collages on the classroom walls and have everyone look at the work. Students can examine how well each collage fits the key points of fair use. Then they can vote for the “best fair use collage” in class.

Option 2: High Tech – Fair Use Remix Video
Have students use www.masher.com to create a remix video. Masher is a free, easy-to-use video remix tool that offers “royalty free” (public domain) music and video content from the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC). Students will need an email address to create a free account. Students can upload copyrighted images, video, and music to masher.com and remix them using the “Studio” editing tool. If you are concerned with students uploading their own content, provide them with images, music, or movie clips to use. For example, you can provide all students with the same: image, song, and video clip to upload. Tell them they all have to use these three elements in their remix. They also can use the royalty-free content on Masher.com (although using all royalty-free content is not technically fair use). When students are done with their remixes, show them in class. Have students examine how well each remix fits the key points of fair use. Then they can vote for the “best fair use remix video” in class.

Wrap-up (5 minutes)

You can use these questions to assess your students’ understanding of the lesson objectives. You may want to ask students to reflect in writing on one of the questions, using a journal or an online blog/wiki.

ASK: What does it mean when we “rework” copyrighted material?
We reuse it, remix it, or use it in a new way.

ASK: How can you tell if something is fair use? 
Students should refer to the four points of fair use.

ASK: Even if you create something that’s fair use, why is it important to give credit to the work you used to make it?
Students should be able to name the three rules for online travel from Teach 1 and their student handouts.

EXTENSION ACTIVITY

Have students explore Creative Commons by being a Copyright Detective. Distribute copies of the Copyright Detectives Student Handout to all students. Refer to the Copyright Detectives Student Handout — Teacher Version for guidance. For this activity, show the video “Whose Is It, Anyway?”. Hit “pause” at the very end of the video, when the Creative Commons license appears. Have students complete the worksheet and share their answers.

AT-HOME ACTIVITY

Have students show their collage or video remix to family members. Students then explain fair use to family members, showing how they reworked copyrighted material in order to make something new and original.